← All work

Strategic Marketing · IMC analysis · Group project

HiSmile: Prove It

Hismile grew from a Gold Coast start-up into a global oral-care brand through influencers and social proof. Then regulators in three countries found that some of that proof was staged. We audited the brand's IMC strategy and proposed a campaign to win trust back with evidence.

Course
Strategic Marketing, Bond University
Type
Group project, team of five
My role
Wrote three of the analysis sections
Result
85.6/100, High Distinction

Acting as marketing consultants, our team picked a real brand with an active multi-channel presence. We had to critically audit its integrated marketing communications (IMC), then redesign its creative strategy. We also had to reflect on how we used generative AI along the way.

We chose Hismile: founded on the Gold Coast in 2014, now sold in more than 40,000 stores worldwide, and built almost entirely on social media.

I worked in a team of five and wrote three of the report's analysis sections:

  • Strategic assumptions and credibility: testing the belief that creator-made social proof is the best way to win customers, against what regulators found.
  • Structural challenges: tracing the same misleading-claims problem through regulators in the UK, Australia and the US.
  • Communication technologies: how retargeting and social listening support the strategy, and where content checks fell behind.

The pattern I traced across three markets became the thread of the whole report, and the base the "Prove It" campaign was built on.

“The engine behind every strategic decision.”Marker's feedback on my structural challenges section

Auditing the IMC strategy

We mapped how Hismile uses TikTok for discovery, Instagram for lifestyle content and YouTube Shorts for education. Influencer seeding and user-generated content tie the three together. We segmented the audience demographically (Gen Z and young millennials), psychographically (whitening as part of a daily beauty routine) and behaviourally (trend-driven buyers, ingredient-conscious buyers and loyal repeat users).

Testing the core assumption

The strategy assumes that creator-made social proof is the most effective way to convert customers. We tested this assumption against independent evidence. In 2026 the ACCC fined Hismile for staged videos in which employees posed as shoppers, and for misleading product claims. The UK's advertising regulator and a US advertising watchdog had also taken action.

United KingdomAdvertising Standards AuthorityTwo TikTok ads ruled misleading and exaggerated
AustraliaACCC$138,600 fine and seven infringement notices
United StatesNational Advertising DivisionReferred to the FTC over "instant whitening" claims
One problem, three markets: the pattern I traced in the structural challenges section.

Weighing the alternatives

We considered two other directions before choosing a final one. The first was identity-led messaging built on self-expression. We rejected it because it doesn't fix broken trust. The second was a purely technical transparency campaign. We rejected it because it's too dry to hold a social-first audience.

i.

Social proof built the brand

Influencer credibility drove awareness and growth, reaching A$700m in gross sales by 2024.

ii.

Scale outpaced governance

Misleading content ran across four platforms for two years, so the content checks clearly hadn't kept up with how much the brand was posting.

iii.

Trust drives purchase

Research shows that trust in branded content is the strongest driver of purchase intention. Once that trust breaks, the whole strategy weakens.

iv.

Human judgement mattered

AI tools first framed Hismile as a simple success story. Our own research found the regulatory failures that became the centre of the report.

“The campaign doesn't ask consumers to trust Hismile. It invites them to watch Hismile prove it.”

Prove It is a 12-week TikTok and Instagram campaign. In each video, a culturally relevant personality and an independent oral-care professional test Hismile's claims on camera. The professional is contractually free to give an honest verdict. The tone is self-aware: the brand admits it was caught, and that admission becomes the content.

SMART objectives

+15 ptsBrand trust among 18 to 34-year-olds in Australia and the US, within 12 months
+20%Organic engagement (saves, shares and comments), within six months
−40%Negative sentiment about product claims, within 12 months

85.6 / 100

High Distinction. The project showed how to audit a real brand's communications critically, and turn its biggest weakness into the idea for its next campaign.

Next project

Students under pressure →